Showing posts with label high school dropout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label high school dropout. Show all posts

Friday, August 19, 2011

Congratulations to Darlington Superintendent Rainey Knight

It appears that Darlington's public schools have discovered and are using some effective strategies to reduce its high school dropout rate. The question for the rest of us is, What is Darlington -- and Superintendent Rainey Knight -- doing that can be replicated elsewhere?

The Darlington County School District lowered its high school dropout rate by 0.2 percentage points in 2009 – 2010 from 1.4 percent to 1.2 percent, the seventh lowest rate in the state among South Carolina’s 85 public school districts, according to data released by the S.C. Department of Education.

South Carolina’s high school dropout rate for grades nine through 12 decreased from 3.4 percent to 2.9 percent in 2009 – 2010.

Since 2006 – 2007, Darlington County’s dropout rate for grades nine through 12 has declined from 2.7 percent to 1.2 percent, according to State Department figures. The state’s rate for the same period has dropped from 3.8 percent to 2.9 percent.

“We’re very excited about the improvement in our dropout rate,” said Superintendent of Education Dr. Rainey Knight. “This is one additional factor that shows we’re doing a much better job helping our students stay in school and continue their education until they graduate from high school. I’m very proud of the job our teachers are doing.”

A cursory glance at what Superintendent Rainey Knight told the Florence Morning News shows at least one strategy in effect: Giving education professionals respect and praise for their work.

I wish the Morning News had focused more on Darlington's successful strategies than it did. Rather, it asked for input from General Mick Zais, state su-pretendent of education, and published a paragraph of his talking points.

As Superintendent Knight is the chief educational officer of her district, and her district appears to be making strides in this area, I hope the Morning News will look for another opportunity soon to ask Knight, and the education professionals in her schools, for more information about their most effective dropout prevention strategies.

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Teachers must be doing something right, right?

If fewer high school students are dropping out of school, doesn't it mean that teachers are doing something right? Will Superintendent Mick Zais say that? Will he give any credit at all to the hardworking men and women who teach in South Carolina's public schools?

More than 800 fewer students dropped out of state high schools in 2010 than in the previous year, according to a new report from the South Carolina Department of Education.

The decrease during 2009-10 was the second consecutive year of improvement in reducing dropout numbers. Since 2007-08, the state’s total high school dropouts have decreased from 8,032 to 6,265 - a 22 percent improvement.

Zais said improved dropout rates are a critical step toward improved on-time high school graduation rates, which he views as a key measurement of success for the entire K-12 system.

"We have to make certain that kids stay focused and engaged from the first day of kindergarten through high school graduation," Zais said.

"Students must have basic reading skills by third grade to successfully complete high school. Offering parents a full menu of schools to choose for their students will enable them to find the best fit their learning styles. Technology allows schools to deliver customized learning experiences rather than one-size-fits-all instruction to every student.

"There is no silver bullet to magically improve high school graduation rates, but by focusing on the needs of students, we can and will make progress."

So, school choice and technology is to thank for the decrease in dropout rates? Teachers had nothing to do with it?

This, Superintendent Zais, is why you garner so little respect from South Carolina's rank-and-file classroom instructors. Given a gold-plated opportunity to praise the hard work of our education professionals, you toss it away and give the credit to "a full menu of schools to choose," and technology.

A little unsolicited advice: Teachers have hard jobs; those superintendents who have spent time as classroom instructors know this. And teachers -- who are, after all, people -- feel better about the work they do when they don't have to worry about being attacked from behind by a leader who disregards their contribution to the profession and to their communities, who values them so little, and who may indeed despise them. Yes, Superintendent Zais, it's just that obvious. Word gets around.

To ameliorate their anxiety, since you presently occupy the seat that South Carolina's chief public school advocates have occupied in the past, you might consider being graceful -- even grand -- and crediting our state's teachers and school district employees for the good, hard work that they do.

And if anyone asks who gave you the idea to do it, claim it was your idea; it'll make you feel good, I guarantee.

As for the decrease in high school dropout rates, mirabile dictu, South Carolina's teachers and school district employees have been pulling a heavy load and then some:

The 2010 dropout report found improvements in all demographic groups.

Included were a decrease in African-American dropouts from 3,579 in 2007-08 to 2,724 in 2009-10 and a decrease in dropouts from high-poverty families from 4,451 in 2007-08 to 3,768 in 2009-10. Hispanic dropouts decreased from 399 in 2007-08 to 322 in 2009-10.

Looking at specific grades, the best progress in reducing dropouts occurred among 9th-graders, with 2,342 9th-graders dropping out in 2007-08 compared to 1,691 9th-graders dropping out in 2009-10.

Ninth-graders made up 29 percent of total high school dropouts in 2007-08, but 27 percent last year.

Congratulations to our high school students and all those professionals who work hard to meet their needs every day.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

To lower dropout rates, teach young children to love reading

Sometimes, the simplest solutions are the best ones.

A study from the Annie E. Casey Foundation suggests that we should start addressing the dropout problem well before children become teenagers. It turns out that reading to small children, and encouraging them to read, may be the most effective strategy to reduce the high school dropout rate.

It's a challenge, sure. South Carolina's lawmakers have never been keen on long-term strategies, as the business community measures its profits and losses in quarterly reports. But if we're serious about fixing the dropout rate, maybe we ought to pay attention to this one.

Children who aren't reading proficiently by third grade are four times more likely not to graduate high school than their peers with higher reading skills, according to a report issued Friday.

Students in low-income families fared even worse in a longitudinal study of 3,975 children born between 1979 and 1989, according to Double Jeopardy: How Third-Grade Reading Skills and Poverty Influence High School Graduation, a report commissioned by the Annie E. Casey Foundation and presented during the Education Writers Association's national conference in New Orleans.

"We will never close the achievement gap, we will never solve our dropout crisis, we will never break the cycle of poverty that afflicts so many children if we don't make sure that all our students learn to read," said Ralph Smith, the foundation's executive vice president, in a statement. "This research confirms the compelling need to address the underlying issues that keep children from reading."

The Casey study finds that one-sixth of third-graders who don't read on a third-grade level don't graduate on time. Of those third-graders measured to have the lowest skills level -- "below basic" -- almost one-fourth drop out, compared with nine percent of children who demonstrate the "basic" skills level and four percent of those who demonstrate "proficient" reading skills.

A second large theme found by the Casey study is the role of childhood poverty.

Overall, 22 percent of children who have lived in poverty do not graduate high school, compared with 6 percent who have never been poor. And 32 percent of students spending more than half their childhood in poverty do not finish high school on time.

For children who were in poverty at least one year and who were not reading proficiently in third grade, 26 percent didn't graduate on time -- more than six times the rate for all proficient readers.

It would seem to be self-evident, wouldn't it, that children lacking fundamental resources in the home -- clean water, good nutrition, a book here or there -- would have a harder time gaining the basic skills necessary to succeed in school. Yet despite study after study demonstrating these conclusions in clear, incontrovertible terms, South Carolina continues to leave large populations of its children in poverty. The 2010 census suggests that something approaching half of the state's children suffer there now.

The Casey study's full conclusions are outlined here, and the writers at the Augusta Chronicle suggest that "if those trends hold beyond the study group, Georgia and South Carolina have tougher challenges than many other states."

In Georgia, only 29 percent of fourth-graders scored at or above the proficient level on National Assessment of Educational Progress reading tests in 2009. In South Carolina, the rate was 28 percent; and nationally, it was 33.

Facing an even more difficult challenge, based on 2010 poverty levels, are Burke County (83.6 percent of students eligible for free or reduced-price lunch, a measure of poverty), Richmond County (74 percent), McDuffie County (71.6 percent), Edgefield County (58.3 percent) and Aiken County (56.7 percent).

So, what lessons should we take from the Casey study?

"These findings suggest we need to work in three arenas: improving the schools where these children are learning to read, helping the families weighed down by poverty and encouraging better federal, state and local policy to improve the lot of both schools and families," said Donald J. Hernandez, a sociology professor who conducted the study.

Sounds costly, which means the legislature will likely leave it to a future legislature to handle, when the economy improves. For now, we've got budget cuts to enact -- and drivers licenses to take away from teenagers missing school.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

School budget cuts threaten for-profit and non-profit programs

A little-known bit of No Child Left Behind, a law still inflicting harm well past its expiration date, was a provision forcing school districts labeled "low-performing" for three consecutive years to devote 15 percent of its federal funds to private-sector "supplemental education services" programs. It hadn't occurred to me before reading this morning's Greenville News that in a time when federal funds for public education are running out and none come from the stingy state to replace them, those private entities who profited marvelously only a few years ago from public funding might now be starving, too.

Today's News mentions a "privately funded organization" offering summer courses at Travelers Rest High School, and the organization's dire straits in perilous budget times. I have no idea whether the program, "Graduate Greenville," was one of the supplemental education service programs funded by NCLB, but budget cuts do appear to be negatively impacting its business.

Graduate Greenville provides graduation coaches in five high schools in Greenville County who help more than 200 students who were at risk of dropping out.

Whether it will be able to continue operating in that many schools, however, is in doubt, as the organization faces a shortfall in funding from foundations and private donors hard hit by the recession, said Ted Hendry, president of the United Way of Greenville County and a member of the Graduate Greenville board of directors.

"We have confidence that we will be in at least one school going forward," he said. "And we will be working from April to December to identify funding sources for beyond the 2011-12 school year."

Welcome to the world that public educators have inhabited for their whole lives. It's a sad day when the state's aristocratic ideologues stop funding their pet programs in the private sector.

Begun in 2005, Graduate Greenville was born out of a collaboration among the school district, the United Way and the independent, nonprofit booster organization Public Education Partners, formerly the Alliance for Quality Education. Its goal was to improve the high school graduation rate in Greenville County, said Marge Scieszka, director.
...
The program costs about $485,000 for five sites, $150,000 of which comes from the United Way, Hendry said.

That's a pretty penny for services already available for free through the public school system -- or that would be available for free if budget cuts didn't rule them out.

But this is a nice example of the ideology that opposes public education and its services. There is an element among us that believes any service provided at no cost by government agency could be offered by private enterprise instead, and garner a profit, if the government would remove itself from the free market.

What services are we talking about? The News outlines them when it mentions one of the enterprise's employees:

Perry works individually with each of his 54 students about once a week and meets with them as a group every few weeks, he said. He also works with their families, and their teachers, in addressing the issues that have put them at risk of dropping out.

He checks their attendance, grades and behavioral records and works with them to develop the communication skills, study skills and organization skills they need to survive in high school, he said.

If memory serves, this describes the very services offered by school social workers, when they were funded. I wonder what was the profit margin for the "privately funded organization" providing "Graduate Greenville"?

Some students who consider dropping out are dealing with problems at home, or financial problems, Perry said.

But "sometimes it's somewhere along the line they did not get the basics in math and English and it's very difficult for them," he said.

Beyond helping them get caught up on academics, he tries to show his students the possibilities for their lives and give them a sense of the value of sticking with school.

A sign on his classroom door gives notice that "No Slackers" are allowed and lists the positive attributes for success, such as being a "problem solvin', positive thinkin', example settin'" person.

The slangy jargon is an added attraction, I suppose. But I wonder what's meant when " 'no slackers' are allowed." Does the program give "slackers" the boot? I wonder what that's like, as public schools don't have the luxury to send "slackers" home.

But this is quite familiar:

"Sometimes just getting them to understand the importance of why they're here is the biggest part of my job," he said. "Motivation is a key factor, and it can be a very difficult thing to convey to a teenager sometimes."

Ask a retired public school teacher for tips. Better yet, pay a retired public school teacher for his or her advice. Since they're no longer public employees, I'm sure their expertise would be worth a retainer fee in the private sector.

The Graduate Greenville board will meet this month to decide what it will be able to fund for the 2011-12 school year, said Grier Mullins, a board member and executive director of Public Education Partners.

"We've applied for grants. We hope to get some," she said. "We do need to get more funding to continue the program at more than one school."

Good luck with that. The education business isn't what it used to be, back in the golden age when it wasn't a business.

Friday, April 1, 2011

Bill proposes to leave high school dropouts idle in the streets

Again, South Carolina lawmakers propose to criminalize poverty and the poor judgment that stems often from few options. Consider the plight of teenagers growing up in poverty -- this isn't difficult; there are hundreds of thousands of them -- who see one big difference between attending high school classes Monday through Friday and holding down a "right-to-work-for-less" job at a fast food restaurant or a local body shop: a paycheck. All they need is a set of wheels and gas money.

Not so fast.

South Carolina legislators are debating whether to suspend driving licenses of students who drop out of school. Educators in the area are split on the bill’s effectiveness. The bill, which was considered Wednesday in a House subcommittee, provides for suspending the license of a teen who leaves school, is expelled or accumulates more than seven unexcused absences.

Schools would be required to report the absences of 15- to 17-year-olds to the Department of Motor Vehicles.


Thirty seconds of an internet search tells me that

S.C. compulsory education code sets the age at 17. Exceptions in the code allows a minor to leave school at age 16 with approval from the court of jurisdiction. (S.C. Code, Education, Article 1, Sect: 59-65-10(A) to Sect: 59-65-30 (C)

So even sixteen-year-olds can legally leave school enrollment under current state law, but the new proposal would leave that sixteen-year-old cooling his heels on the porch or driving without a license.

And does anyone else share my view that schools and school districts have enough to do without reporting student absences to the Department of Motor Vehicles? The same lawmakers who shout so loudly against a "nanny state" seem to love making schools play the nanny when it suits them.

Devon Smith, principal of Crescent High School in Iva-based Anderson School District 3, said he thought the proposal didn’t meet the needs of the student.

“It’s just not nearly as simple as the legislators think. There are a lot of other issues surrounding why kids drop out of school,” Smith said. “What if that child has to work to support the family? How are they going to do that if they lose their license?”

Smith said his school’s dropout rate, or the number of students the school cannot account for at the end of their senior year, is 3.5 percent, or about seven students. The bill would not help students as much as it would hinder schools, he said.

Ralph Dillingham, principal of the Anderson County Alternative School, said the move sounded like another layer of bureaucracy.

“I think the idea is good to try to encourage kids in school,” Dillingham said. “But the enforcement of that is just another something the schools would be required to do. That would be my only concern. Is it the right place to try to enforce this? It seems to me the burden for supervising this would fall to schools but there wouldn’t be any more resources to oversee it with.”

The Anderson County Alternative School provides a middle school and high school setting for students across the county who have been expelled and chose to attend the school.

Dillingham said he was not familiar with the particulars of the bill, but felt it would be unfair to penalize students like those in his school who are technically expelled, but are attending school.

I want students to stay in school and graduate, too. But I've known plenty of students whose family suffered when a single parent suffered an illness, had no insurance, and lost a job in our right-to-work-for-less state. Such students, even at age 15 or 16, find that budget cuts to public assistance mean the Hamburger Helper doesn't stretch very far, and that even a menial job at McDonald's comes with perks like meals. Who's the criminal? We, who agree to cutting holes in the social safety net we pretend to hold up for the poorest and weakest among us, or the teenagers who choose a paying job over remedial reading?

Difficult question. But I'm not ready to criminalize poverty just yet.