Showing posts with label Mia Butler Garrick. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mia Butler Garrick. Show all posts

Monday, April 23, 2012

Lawmakers acknowledge inequity in school funding

In South Carolina, good ideas are rare to emerge from our State House -- no sense denying the truth -- but every good idea is chained at the waist to two or three bad ones.

Here's an example, as reported by WTLX:

A bi-partisan group of South Carolina legislators wants to create a uniform education funding system that boosts funding for most students while cutting property taxes for businesses and rental owners.

Catch that? One step forward, two steps back.

Arithmetic is simple. One plus one equals two. Five plus five equals ten. Ten is more than two.

Today, some schools are getting level-two funding. Some are getting level-ten funding. That's unequal.

Funding comes from tax revenue.

It's a great idea to create a single pot of tax revenue out of which all schools can be funded equitably.

It's a foolish idea to cut the tax revenue that will go into that pot, because cutting the tax revenue means that there's fewer dollars in the pot to improve school funding.

Republican Rep. Jenny Horne of Summerville led a news conference Tuesday calling for a revamping of South Carolina's fragmented, decades-old education funding formulas.

The five Republicans and one Democrat say a bill will be filed Wednesday to jumpstart the conversation.

The concept involves creating a statewide system of property tax billing for school operations and spending the same on students statewide. The amount per child would be weighted with additional spending, for example, for poor students and gifted and talented students.

Here's where this proposal will fail: By cutting tax revenues, these lawmakers are telling communities whose schools are currently funded at level-ten that they're going to have to settle for level-six funding, in order to raise level-twos up to level-six too.

They're not going to go for that, which means this has been an exercise in futility. You don't feed more children equitably by making the pie smaller; you feed more children equitably by making the pie bigger.

Most businesses would get a tax break.

Well, of course they would. This is South Carolina; night follows day, and the sun rises in the East.

Here's coverage of the same topic by the South Carolina Radio Network:

A group of state legislators unveiled a new proposal Tuesday that would make major changes to how public schools are funded in South Carolina.

Rep. Jenny Horne (R-Summerville) called the idea a "win-win" for public education and business.

A bipartisan group of lawmakers want to set a single property tax millage rate across the entire state and put that money into a single pot. That money would then be divided up on a per-pupil basis and sent back to districts, with weighted amounts for students with disabilities, low income or other factors.

The idea is to replace the state’s four-decade-old funding formula that has become a patchwork of different tax rates and funding levels.

“We’ve got 85 school districts in this state. We’ve got 85 different funding formulas,” said Sen. Paul Campbell (R-Goose Creek), who plans to introduce the proposal in the Senate Wednesday. “What we need is a comon funding formula in this state.”

A group of five Republicans and one Democratic legislator held a press conference in the Statehouse lobby Tuesday to unveil the proposal.

“We’ve heard for years that the money needs to follow the child,” Rep. Doug Brannon (R-Landrum) said, “Under the current education funding process, that’s just not possible.”

Brannon said education funding reform is needed before lawmakers can start tax reform, since property taxes mostly go towards schools and education makes up more than half of the state’s General Fund spending. While unlikely to pass this late in the session, Rep. Jenny Horne (R-Summerville) said it is meant to start a conversation for next year’s session.

Education groups agreed. Debbie Elmore of the South Carolina Association of School Boards said she was glad lawmakers recognized the need to change how school districts are funded. “It’s like a blast of cool water on a hot day. It’s refreshing.”

Molly Spearman, executive director of the South Carolina Association of School Administrators, said the original formula was created in the 1970s and has not been updated since– meaning many counties treated as “rural” under the formula have since seen a significant growth. Others are still treated as if they have a textile mill tax base, when that has not been the case for decades.

Horne called the new proposal a “win-win”: most residents and businesses would see a property tax decrease, while school districts would get a more efficient funding formula.

“This is where the campaign rhetoric ends and true, meaningful tax reform begins,” said Rep. Mia Butler-Garrick (D-Columbia), who joined Republicans in introducing the bill.

The bill will propose a uniform rate of 100 mills rate (a mill equals $1 of property taxed per $1,000 of its assessed value), which would be a decrease in 43 of the state’s 46 counties. Horne said lawmakers would work to find ways to keep the remaining counties (Beaufort, Charleston, and Georgetown) below that rate so that they will not be the only ones to suffer a tax increase.

Thursday, January 19, 2012

Garrick bypasses Zais: A law whose time has come

This is precisely why we have legislators and a legislature in the first place -- to check executive power. Kudos to Rep. Mia Butley Garrick for her advocacy for public education.

From the current edition of Columbia's Free Times:

Superintendent Mick Zais’ controversial stance against accepting federal education grants will soon spark a battle in the legislative chambers.

Rep. Mia Butler Garrick, a Richland County Democrat, recently introduced legislation that would prohibit the state’s top education official from turning down any federal education grant that does not require matching funds.

“I just don’t understand why our superintendent of education would not want to accept all new available federal dollars for education,” she said.

It may have something to do with his ideological opposition to strengthening public education for the 700,000 children enrolled in South Carolina's traditional public schools. But I could be wrong; he may want to love public schools and simply not know how to love them.

Zais hasn’t shut the door on all federal grants, but he recently refused to apply for two federal programs that could have injected millions into the state’s education resources.

One of the programs, the Ed Jobs grant, would have given South Carolina access to $144 million. Another, the Race to the Top program, would have allowed the state to compete for a portion of $200 million in federal funds.

Zais contends such programs equate to federal mandates because of all of the requirements imposed on the state.

Federal highway dollars have the exact same "requirements": accept the federal highway money, and you have to spend the money on building and maintaining highways. Similarly, federal education dollars must be spent on providing educational services to children through public schools. What's the confusion?

But Garrick dismisses the “too many strings attached” rhetoric as a partisan argument often heard in national political circles.

She says South Carolina is not in a position to refuse such grants, and failure to use them amounts to “sabotage” of the education system.

We have a winner. Johnny Olsen, tell the lady what she's won.

Zais spokesman Jay Ragley said the superintendent’s position on such programs was well known when he was elected to office.

Well, to be fair, the good General was running for an office called "Superintendent of Education," and people -- dumb as we are -- tend to infer that if you run for "Superintendent of Education," you might support public schools. Crazy us for thinking that, sure.

So, to help those slower-thinking ones among us, the good General might have offered plainer statements such as, "I oppose the rights of your children to be educated in schools supported by our collective financial resources through tax revenue, and therefore I will do everything within my power to end this scheme of public education as rapidly as my little hands can work, once I take the reins of power in that tall building. Little poor children will have no more access to teachers and books, you can count on that. And if the federal government thinks it can stop me from bringing alllll of our educational progress in South Carolina to a screeching halt, it's got another think a-comin'!"

See, statements like that might've more accurately communicated to the 'lectorate what the General was thinking.

“Respectfully, General Zais opposes this legislation because it silences the voice of the voters,” Ragley said in an email response to the Free Times.

Here, we have a classic example of something called "spin." Political operatives with no background in public education are expert at "spin," and the General has hired a passel of them to speak for him. Here's some more of it:

“In 2010, the voters spoke loud and clear, electing Gen. Zais by a margin of victory in excess of 108,000 votes,” Ragley said. “Gen. Zais has repeatedly called for more, not less, local control of schools so they have the freedom to personalize and customize education for every student.”

It's called "spin" because, in this instance, the virtue of "local control" has been invoked as a fragile and beautiful flower, threatened by boogeyman of federal education dollars. See, by drawing your attention to the pretty flower, this operative has "spun" your attention away from the asininity of depriving our state's public schoolchildren of millions, and millions, and millions of federal education dollars.

Operatives are excellent at spin; they are also excellent at asininity. It's a fact in the Library of Congress.

Garrick said her bill may face something of an uphill battle in the Republican-dominated General Assembly.

Every good thing that has been decent and righteous and worth having or doing has faced an uphill battle in our fair state.

But she says she has bipartisan support.

“I know there are some Republicans who will support this bill,” she said. She expects deliberations on the bill will begin in the House Ways and Means Committee.

The displeasure over Zais’ back-turning on federal grants is widespread. About 50 education advocates and protesters gathered at the State House in December to protest his actions. The rally was organized by the state Legislative Black Caucus, whose members are all Democrats, and the state chapter of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.

The South Carolina Association of School Administrators and the South Carolina School Boards Association have also denounced Zais’ position.

“We would hope that our state superintendent of education would welcome the opportunity to seek resources to help our state’s growing population of at-risk children,” said the two groups.

The S.C. Board of Education has been at odds with Zais over various issues, and at one point sought to require him to report on any federal or private grant exceeding $10 million for which South Carolina schools are eligible, and to justify his decision on whether to apply.

Zais argued the board has no authority over him and that he reports to voters, not the board.

Translation: This ball is my ball. If you do not have a ball, too bad for you. This ball is mine, and I say who gets to play with it, and I say what we will play. You may not play with my ball if I say you may not, so if you want to play with my ball, you must agree with me on all things. Plus, I don't have to talk to you if I don't want to. I control my ball. You do not. You are not my boss, so you cannot tell me what me what to do with my ball. It's mine. Mine, all mine.

The disagreements were later patched up after the board’s new chairman, Dennis Thompson, met with Zais and agreed to put the issue behind them and move ahead in a spirit of cooperation.

Translation: Our state's board of education agreed that it would not ever again suggest to Mick Zais what he should do with his ball, because the ball is his ball. Agreement that the superintendent has a ball and controls it, and the state board of education has no ball and controls nothing, represents cooperation.

Zais also came under fire from Democrats for failing to request more money for education in the coming year. Zais asked the Ways and Means panel not to make any cuts in the budget that provides the basic funding for classrooms, but he did not ask for an increase.

His first term as superintendent will continue to stir emotions as critics see his refusal to accept federal funds for education as a flagrant disregard for the needs of public education.

That's no joke. If we're not already searching out good candidates to replace Zais and his operatives, we have only ourselves to blame.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Garrick identifies hypocrisies in South Carolina's budget proposal

Lodging charges of hypocrisy in South Carolina's budget is almost too easy -- like shooting fish in a barrel -- but I have to promote the interesting perspective of freshman Rep. Mia Butler Garrick, whose reflection on the recent two-day House budget debate is insightful. You can read the whole essay here but she names four obstacles to South Carolina's progress: the "good ol' boy system," the waste of time, the "lack of political courage" and lawmakers' "rhetoric."

Garrick offers suggestions to ameliorate our collective condition:

We could start by repealing Act 388, at least considering the Taxation Realignment Commission’s recommendations or rethinking last year’s unemployment insurance increase.

And if we’re serious about shrinking government, let’s not create new positions such as inspector general or a new agency such as the Department of Administration while maintaining the Budget and Control Board. Consolidating agencies is a great idea, but only if it saves money, eliminates duplication and streamlines services.

I support government restructuring because I believe South Carolina needs true government reform. I’m just not convinced that our efforts in the budget the House just passed truly accomplish that.

She critiques the budget debate as "unbelievably short" and uncorks on the bill's inherent hypocrisies:

I voted against it because our priorities are misaligned. There are a few positives, such as an increase in base student funding for education, $25 million for public charter schools and $10 million for the Department of Commerce’s deal-closing fund to help recruit new businesses to South Carolina.

But there are numerous hypocrisies: Creating a new government agency and new positions while saying we’re not growing government. Funding large salary increases in the governor’s office while cutting essential programs and services. Reducing access to quality, affordable health care while turning federal money away that could expand access and save jobs.

During our budget debate, the majority rejected a federal 3-to-1 return on state tax dollars that could bring millions to the state and save jobs that we desperately need right now. Meanwhile, hard-working South Carolinians are losing their jobs, their homes, their health care, their quality of life — making it difficult even to survive the current economic conditions, let alone thrive.

And while the establishment successfully incited fear across South Carolina in anticipation of more devastating cuts this year, the reality is that we have again balanced the state’s budget on the backs of hard-working middle-class South Carolinians who can least afford it.

As a student of our state's tortured history, I regretfully submit that the only way to change our malignant system is through a constitutional convention. History demonstrates that only those overhauls to our foundation document have yielded significant change in the past. But I am immeasurably loathe to support that option, because I suspect the physicians at hand would render a cure deadlier than the illness.

No, South Carolina's salvation lay another two or three generations ahead.